13:04:53 From Matthew David to Everyone: Working Circles with the US Forest Service are now available. You can sign up to participate here (scroll to the bottom): https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/17ry5-PdWi2UjPUk_VAHZv9MtkMCc7Fuu0laltWsKcOU/edit#gid=0 13:12:13 From sujata to Everyone: I cannot help but cringe at this analysis. I don’t feel worthy to evaluate it. Is this the exact text or how it was delivered? 13:14:05 From Matthew David to Everyone: I believe this is word for word how it was delivered. 13:14:16 From devo brown to Everyone: i feel good we’re studying the brilliance of it 13:29:56 From Neena Anandaraman to Everyone: 3 13:29:58 From sujata to Everyone: 6 13:30:00 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: 3 13:30:01 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: 3 13:30:04 From Mike Quizon to Everyone: 4 13:30:04 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: 7 13:30:05 From Paul Zankowski to Everyone: 2 13:30:07 From Rich Derksen/OCS, DC to Everyone: 8 13:30:08 From devo brown to Everyone: 3 13:30:16 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: big range 13:30:26 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: Nice range! 13:31:30 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: it just seems like a recap of results 13:31:36 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: This kind of range is not surprising... 13:33:17 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: This is how LOTS of abstracts and short talks are written...especially speed talks at meetings. 13:33:26 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: 6 13:33:31 From Rich Derksen/OCS, DC to Everyone: 4 13:33:32 From Neena Anandaraman to Everyone: 8 13:33:32 From Paul Zankowski to Everyone: 6 13:33:34 From Mike Quizon to Everyone: 7 13:33:39 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: To be fair, I rated it on your criteria... but as an abstract #1 would be perfectly reasonable for a poster 13:33:39 From devo brown to Everyone: 6 13:33:39 From sujata to Everyone: 3 13:33:44 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: 8 13:35:32 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: 4 13:35:39 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: The trick in this (and it's not easy) is to look past the CONTENT and look at the structure 13:36:03 From sujata to Everyone: Funny enough I think this was the Nobel winner. Yet it still is not my fave abstract. 13:36:30 From sujata to Everyone: I love a secreted protein story any day. Yay eukaryotes. 13:37:33 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: All passive voixe 13:37:37 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Voice 13:38:00 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: you must be in the inner circle sujata 13:38:46 From sujata to Everyone: Hahaha… I did a lot of microscopy and Secreted protein fluorescence is so fun to watch videos of. 13:38:59 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: 6 13:39:04 From Paul Zankowski to Everyone: 6 13:39:04 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: 6 13:39:06 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: 3 13:39:07 From Mike Quizon to Everyone: 4 13:39:07 From Rich Derksen/OCS, DC to Everyone: 4 13:39:11 From devo brown to Everyone: 4 13:39:13 From Neena Anandaraman to Everyone: 2 13:39:14 From sujata to Everyone: 4 13:40:21 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: 3-Flailing 13:42:39 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: Properly done, I think it would leave you thinking how are the choices made and not have to tell it to you. 13:42:55 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Leaves you hanging 13:43:09 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: Step back and ask Randy's second question...what is the problem? 13:43:20 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: There are several 13:43:28 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Kurt V would have this going off a cliff 13:44:15 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: The first three sentences are cohesive and work well together...the question (which could have been a good mechanism) leads into a muddled ending 13:44:21 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: 7 13:44:21 From Neena Anandaraman to Everyone: 9 13:44:22 From Mike Quizon to Everyone: 7 13:44:24 From devo brown to Everyone: 9 13:44:24 From Paul Zankowski to Everyone: 8 13:44:25 From Rich Derksen/OCS, DC to Everyone: 9 13:44:26 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: 8 13:44:27 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: 8 13:44:28 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: 8 13:44:45 From sujata to Everyone: 7 13:44:49 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: Is this a movie you wrote Matt? 13:44:56 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Brevity is the soul of wit 13:45:05 From devo brown to Everyone: yup 13:45:10 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: Cliffhanger 13:45:14 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Teaser 13:45:21 From Mike Quizon to Everyone: ditto 13:45:24 From sujata to Everyone: This is the trailer 13:45:29 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Reacted to "This is the trailer" with 😂 13:46:32 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: This is typical of a movie synopsis...it leaves you hanging from the cliff so you have to go see the movie to find out. 13:47:53 From Neena Anandaraman to Everyone: 0 13:47:53 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: 2 13:47:54 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: Nothing worse than a movie trailer that has every good scene in it.... 13:47:54 From devo brown to Everyone: 3 13:47:56 From Mike Quizon to Everyone: 3 13:47:57 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: 10 13:47:59 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: 2 13:48:00 From Mike Strauss to Everyone: We have a winner! 13:48:00 From Rich Derksen/OCS, DC to Everyone: 2 13:48:01 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: 3 13:48:01 From Paul Zankowski to Everyone: 1 13:48:04 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Nina is not playing today 13:48:04 From sujata to Everyone: 1 13:48:16 From sujata to Everyone: Reacted to "Nina is not playing …" with 😂 13:48:21 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Reacted to "Nina is not playing …" with 😂 13:48:26 From Nick Pallotta (USDA) to Everyone: Maybe this is the movie you wrote? 13:48:30 From devo brown to Everyone: aaaaa 13:48:52 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Dante’s inferno 13:50:03 From sujata to Everyone: Hahaha… clerks 2? 😂 13:51:05 From sujata to Everyone: I did not join the Jay and Silent Bob bandwagon yet. 13:51:14 From William Trenkle, USDA to Everyone: It's still a terrible abstract.... 13:51:33 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Dumb and dumber? 13:52:04 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Can you speak about active versus passive voice? 13:52:05 From sujata to Everyone: Dogma is better… see dogma 13:52:24 From sujata to Everyone: Boo passive voice 13:52:40 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: Yes 13:52:50 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: BUT 13:53:03 From devo brown to Everyone: therefore… 13:53:16 From Rachel F. Steele | She/Her to Everyone: There get the structure correct first 13:53:22 From sujata to Everyone: Scientists have done themselves a disservice. 😝 13:54:14 From sujata to Everyone: It’s just so epic… I felt weird evaluating it in any way. 13:55:40 From sujata to Everyone: 🤷🏽‍♀️😳🙏 13:57:30 From R. Brent Elrod to Everyone: Thanks! 13:57:30 From sujata to Everyone: Can ABT be delivered badly?? 13:57:46 From sujata to Everyone: Ok… excited for examples! 13:57:51 From sujata to Everyone: Bye