13:13:34 From Julie E. Claussen to Everyone: Why should we care about salmon diets? 13:14:14 From Matthew David to Everyone: Details on how to sign up for the ABT Framework Google group are on the Resource Page. Sign up to audit future classes for free and keep participating in Working Circles: http://abtframework.com/abt-framework-student-resource-page-round-35-noaa/#group 13:14:40 From Beth Phillips to Everyone: nearshore habitats matter, but we don't know which ones specifically...therefore we need to know more about salmon diet in specific habitats... 13:14:47 From Darren Howe to Everyone: But we cannot assess the value of various habitat units because we don't know how long individual fish utilize any given stand of submerged aquatic vegetation, Therefore we must study Chinook use of SAV. 13:15:23 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Perfect case of using AND IF.. AND IF we know this... 13:15:31 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: misplaced ecological value? 13:16:07 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Reacted to "But we cannot asse..." with ๐Ÿ‘ 13:16:20 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Reacted to "nearshore habitats..." with ๐Ÿ‘ 13:18:39 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Why do we not have the data? 13:18:51 From Kinsey Frick to Everyone: difficult and expensive to collect 13:19:39 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Replying to "difficult and expens..." So the real problem is money? 13:19:52 From devo brown to Everyone: Reacted to "So the real problem ..." with ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿผ 13:20:06 From devo brown to Everyone: Replying to "difficult and expens..." thatโ€™s the solution 13:20:39 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Oh money is the ultimate goal 13:21:06 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Replying to "Oh money is the ulti..." Sorry proximate goal 13:21:27 From Anne Mullan to Everyone: fishing changes lead to orca changes and council has to adapt 13:21:30 From Anne Mullan to Everyone: cABT? 13:25:38 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Is the endorsement the problem? 13:26:04 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Gear endorsement matters because...Fishing efficiently saves fishers money BUT there's a wrinkle in the plan 13:26:09 From Anne Mullan to Everyone: there is a thing that is endorsed, and a new thing maybe endorsed, but maybe should not be 13:26:10 From Laurie Weitkamp to Everyone: orcas outwit fishermen and council 13:26:23 From Rebecca Thomas to Everyone: Reacted to "orcas outwit fishe..." with ๐Ÿ‘ 13:26:40 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Reacted to "Gear endorsement mat..." with ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿพ 13:26:59 From Anne Mullan to Everyone: Reacted to "orcas outwit fishe..." with ๐Ÿ˜‚ 13:27:04 From Matthew David to Everyone: Reacted to "orcas outwit fisherm..." with ๐Ÿ˜‚ 13:27:18 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Reacted to "orcas outwit fishe..." with ๐Ÿ˜‚ 13:27:31 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Gear endorsement works well if we endorse the right gear but right now it is not working for โ€ฆ.. 13:28:47 From Julie E. Claussen to Everyone: Orcas seem central to the story hereโ€ฆ 13:28:58 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Replying to "Gear endorsement wor..." slinky pots because orcas have found a way to get to the vital catch 13:30:43 From Blane Bellerud to Everyone: Guns don't kill people, people kill people, but there are always people that want to kill other people, therefore we cannot allow people unrestricted access to guns 13:33:23 From Lynn Massey to Everyone: Reacted to "orcas outwit fishe..." with ๐Ÿ˜‚ 13:33:40 From Matthew David to Everyone: Risk Communication on Climate: Mental Models and Mass Balance โ€“ The IPCC Report on climate change is supposed to be simple enough for policy makers to interpret it, but itโ€™s so complicated that even MIT grads with STEM backgrounds canโ€™t decipher it. - http://www.storycirclestraining.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/09/StermanPolicyForum081024.pdf 13:35:27 From Matthew David to Everyone: This is an actionable step you can all take with your writing. If you don't think the narrative is strong and you can't pinpoint why, try color coding it. 13:35:40 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Reacted to "This is an actiona..." with ๐Ÿ‘ 13:36:50 From Matthew David to Everyone: Oprahโ€™s Golden Globes Speech โ€“ A great example of using Nested ABTs. Color coded in the ABT format - http://www.scienceneedsstory.com/2018/01/08/125-oprah-gives-an-abt-tour-de-force/ 13:36:55 From Jean Castillo to Everyone: Matthew, is there a list with all the books that were referenced over the last 10 sessions? 13:38:47 From Matthew David to Everyone: Jean - That...is a great idea! An actual ABT book list. I'll have to get started on that. In the meantime, you can pick them out here and there under the Resource Page sections. 13:38:55 From Matthew David to Everyone: http://abtframework.com/abt-framework-student-resource-page-round-35-noaa/ 13:43:07 From Jean Castillo to Everyone: Thanks Matt! 13:43:57 From Jean Castillo to Everyone: Steve Jobs - โ€œThe most powerful person in the world is the storyteller. The storyteller sets the vision, values, and agenda of an entire generation that is to comeโ€ฆโ€ Read on here.... If you want to change x, y, or z you need to tell the best story. The best storyteller wins. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/steve-jobs-lesson-storytelling-dave-byrne/ 13:44:52 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Replying to " Steve Jobs - โ€œThe m..." Thanks 13:44:58 From Jean Castillo to Everyone: I read this awhile ago and thought it was a very powerful tool in getting the message you want out there. 13:46:52 From Matthew David to Everyone: These two tools, the And Frequency and Narrative Index, are the other actionable thing you can do to check your writing and see if there are any narrative problems 13:48:48 From Matthew David to Everyone: We consider a Narrative Index over 10 to be acceptable. 13:49:27 From Matthew David to Everyone: As a reminder, the ideal And Frequency is 2.5%. We consider over 4% to be deadly levels of boring. 13:50:17 From Matthew David to Everyone: Measure your own writing slide: http://storycirclestraining.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/measure-your-own-writing-slide.png 13:50:50 From Matthew David to Everyone: The word frequency tool to help count your Ands and Buts: https://www.browserling.com/tools/word-frequency 13:51:22 From Matthew David to Everyone: Here's the score ratings slide: http://storycirclestraining.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/and-frequency-and-narrative-index-scores.png 13:57:42 From Laurie Weitkamp to Everyone: What about paper titles? Try to use ABT? 13:59:49 From Jean Castillo to Everyone: good point 14:00:25 From Jean Castillo to Everyone: Thank you very much Randy and Matt. I need to jump off for another call. 14:01:59 From Curt Whitmire to Everyone: Thank you so much, Randy, Matt, our structuralists, and featured guests for such a fun, engaging, and useful course. I'm beginning to drink the Cool-Aid and appreciate learning these principles. I look forward to continuing to put these lessons into practice! 14:02:33 From Julie E. Claussen to Everyone: Really impressed with the group - keep going! 14:02:52 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Reacted to "Really impressed wit..." with ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿพ 14:03:01 From Eli Holmes - NOAA Fisheries to Everyone: Thank you! 14:03:09 From Albertha Joseph-Alexander to Everyone: Bye